Call Now At (208) 345-6308 (Meridian) | (208) 365-4411 (Emmett)
Call Now At (208) 345-6308 (Meridian) | (208) 365-4411 (Emmett)
Thanksgiving should involve passing the potatoes, sharing family stories, and debating who makes the best pie. It should not involve accidentally violating federal gun laws.
But a well-intentioned gift can create exactly that problem.
Imagine this: You live in Idaho. Your adult son lives in Tennessee. He comes home for Thanksgiving, and you decide it is time he had the family handgun. Perhaps it belonged to his grandfather. Perhaps you have always intended for him to have it.
You hand it to him before he heads home.
He is your son. It is your gun. No money changes hands. Surely that is legal.
Unfortunately, common sense and federal firearms law do not always arrive at the same destination.
The problem is that federal law does not treat this as simply a gift between a parent and child. Under the Gun Control Act, specifically 18 U.S.C. § 922(a)(5), a private, unlicensed person generally may not directly transfer a firearm to another unlicensed person whom the giver knows, or has reasonable cause to believe, lives in a different state.
The restriction covers gifts as well as sales. There is no blanket exception for giving a firearm to your adult child.
And having Thanksgiving dinner together in Idaho does not change where either of you lives. The issue is your different states of residence—not simply whether the gun eventually crosses a state line.
Apparently, the family relationship travels more easily than the family handgun.
As a Second Amendment attorney and former District Attorney, I see this kind of mistake far too often. I call it the “accidental felony”: someone trying to do an ordinary, well-intentioned thing encounters a law that defies what most people would consider common sense.
That phrase describes the trap; the precise facts and required mental state still matter in any criminal case. But assuming a family gift must be lawful is a poor substitute for checking the rules.
Fortunately, you can still give your son the handgun. You just need to add a federally licensed firearms dealer to the family’s holiday plans.
For this Idaho-to-Tennessee gift, contact a federally licensed firearms dealer in Tennessee before your son takes possession. Arrange for the handgun to be lawfully shipped or delivered to that dealer. An Idaho dealer can help coordinate the process.
The Tennessee dealer then handles the transfer to your son, including Form 4473, the applicable background-check requirements, and compliance with applicable law. Confirm the receiving dealer’s procedures, fees, and shipping instructions in advance.
Your son should not simply take the handgun home and plan to complete the paperwork later.
Yes, passing down a family heirloom can require a middleman. Congress apparently felt Thanksgiving needed another logistical challenge.
If you are wondering whether leaving the handgun to your son in your will would be different, the answer is yes. Federal law provides an exception for certain interstate transfers through a bequest or intestate succession. In other words, qualifying inheritances after someone dies. The recipient must still be legally eligible, and other applicable laws must be considered.
That exception does not turn “Grandpa wanted you to have this someday” into permission for a lifetime gift between residents of different states. Giving a firearm now and leaving it through an estate can produce different legal requirements.
This is one of the everyday legal traps I explain in my book, Infringed. Responsible gun ownership requires understanding rules that are often far less intuitive than they should be.
Family firearms carry stories, memories, and traditions worth preserving. A little planning can help ensure the next chapter involves your family, not a federal criminal case.
Before you pass down that family firearm, make sure you are passing it legally.
Alexandria Kincaid is a former District Attorney, Second Amendment attorney, and author of Infringed. Her law office is in Emmett, Idaho. This article provides general education, not legal advice for a particular transaction.